Dog Trainer or DIY? How to Choose a Trainer or Obedience Class

When to train your dog yourself and when to get help, types of classes, trainer certifications, questions to ask and red flags to avoid.

Dog Trainer or DIY? How to Choose a Trainer or Obedience Class

Key takeaways

  • Most owners can teach the basics at home, but a good class speeds things up — especially for first-timers.
  • The dog training industry is unregulated — anyone can call themselves a trainer.
  • Look for reward-based methods and credentials such as CPDT-KA, KPA-CTP or IAABC.
  • For aggression or severe anxiety, see a veterinary behaviorist or certified behavior consultant.

You can teach your dog a lot on your own with patience and good information. But a skilled trainer can save you months of frustration — and for some problems, professional help is essential.

Train yourself, take a class, or hire a trainer?

Option Best for Typical cost (U.S.)
DIY (books, videos, guides like ours) Basic manners, motivated owners Low
Group class Puppies, basic obedience, socialization, distraction practice $120–$300 for 4–8 weeks
Private lessons Specific problems, busy schedules, reactive dogs $75–$200+ per session
Board-and-train Rarely recommended for beginners — you still need to learn to maintain training $1,000–$3,000+
Behavior professional Aggression, severe fear or separation anxiety Varies

Types of classes

  • Puppy class (roughly 8–16 weeks): socialization, handling, foundations. See puppy socialization.
  • Basic obedience / manners: sit, down, stay, come, loose-leash walking, polite greetings.
  • Canine Good Citizen (CGC) prep: a well-known test of good manners in public (AKC in the U.S.; similar programs exist elsewhere).
  • Specialty classes: tricks, agility, scent work, reactive dog classes.

Credentials to look for

Dog training isn't regulated, so anyone can call themselves a trainer. Credentials show a trainer has studied learning theory and committed to ethical standards:

  • CPDT-KA / CPDT-KSA — Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers
  • KPA-CTP — Karen Pryor Academy
  • CBCC-KA — certified behavior consultant (CCPDT)
  • IAABC — International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants
  • Fear Free Certified trainers
  • DACVB — Diplomate of the American College of Veterinary Behaviorists (a veterinarian specialist; can prescribe medication)

Questions to ask a trainer

  1. What methods do you use? What happens when a dog gets it wrong?
  2. What equipment do you use or recommend?
  3. What are your qualifications, and how do you keep learning?
  4. Can I watch a class first?
  5. How many dogs are in a class? How many instructors?
  6. Do you guarantee results? (A good trainer can't guarantee behavior — be wary of those who do.)

A good answer to question 1 sounds like: "We reward the behaviors we want, manage the environment to prevent mistakes, and make things easier if the dog struggles."

Red flags

  • Talk of "dominance," "being the alpha" or "pack leader"
  • Use of prong, choke or shock (e-)collars, leash "pops" or physical corrections
  • Guarantees that a problem will be "fixed" quickly
  • Not allowing you to watch or be involved
  • Dogs in class that look stressed, shut down or fearful

When to see a behavior professional

Contact your vet first — pain and illness often cause behavior changes — then a qualified behavior consultant or veterinary behaviorist if your dog:

  • Has bitten, or shows aggression toward people or dogs
  • Panics when left alone (separation anxiety)
  • Has intense fears or phobias
  • Has compulsive behaviors like tail-chasing or constant licking